Examine the relation between autonomy and responsibility
Reflect on the issue of promoting responsibility in an alienating world
Method of the Book
Scientific, empiric approach
Focusing on motivational processes
I'm Only in It for the Money
Behaviorist dogma
Deliver a reward for a specific, identifiable behavior and do so as soon after the behavior as possible; focus on rewards rather than punishments; and be consistent in delivering the rewards.
People are fundamentally passive and will respond only when the environment tempts them with the opportunity to get rewards or avoid punishments.
It assumes that there is no inherent motivation to learn.
Child's innate curiosity as a counter argument to Behaviorist dogma
Intrinsic motivation
Refers to the process of doing an activity for its own sake, of doing an activity for the reward that is inherent in the activity itself.
Being intrinsically motivates has to do with being wholly involved in the activity itself and not with reaching a goal.
Experiments on extrinsic rewards and negative effects of money rewards
Undermined subjects' feelings of personal causation
Turned play into work, and the player into a pawn
People lose interest in activities
People lose contact with their inner selves
The Need for Personal Autonomy
Intrinsic need to feel a sense of personal autonomy or self-determination
Autonomy support increases intrinsic motivation
Giving people choices about how to behave.
When you provide people choice, it leaves them feeling as if you are responsive to them as individuals.
What decreases intrinsic motivation
Threat
Deadlines
Imposed goals
Surveillance
Critical evaluations
Competition
Rewards (given with intention to control)
Any occurrence that undermines feeling of autonomy decreases intrinsic motivation.
Limit setting is still important for promoting responsibility
Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation
Instrumental reason
Modern society evaluates everything in terms of its bottom-line yield, the cost-ratio benefit.
Extrinsic control all too often gets people focused only on the outcomes
This leads to shortcuts that may be sad
Worse learning
Undermines intrinsic motivation
Has detrimental effects on performance of any tasks that require creativity, conceptual understanding, or flexible problem solving.
Do people when they are intrinsically motivated also achieve great outcomes?
Better results in learning
Intrinsic motivation is associated with richer experience, better conceptual understanding, greater creativity, and improved problem solving, relative to external controls.
Pragmatic problems with relying on rewards and controls to motivate people
You cannot easily go back
People will all too likely take the shortest or quickest path
Engaging the World with a Sense of Competence
Meaningful contingencies, or behavior-outcome linkages - fundamental element necessary for motivation
Without appropriate instrumentalities, there will not be productive, motivated behavior (but they are also the means for controlling behavior)
There must be clarity about what behaviors are expected, and what outcomes will result from those instrumental behaviors
People must also feel competent at instrumental behaviors
The need for Competency
Feeling competent is important both for extrinsic motivation and for intrinsic motivation
Competence is a second psychological need - beyond autonomy - that underlies intrinsically motivated behavior
Optimal challenge
Gaining competence is not enough though
Giving feedback
Controlling praise decreases intrinsic motivation
Negative feedback is disastrous
Start by asking what the other's thoughts about what happened
People can typically be accurate in evaluating their own performance
When Society Corrupts
The American Dream as a motivating force
Emphasis on materialism
Extrinsic and intrinsic life aspirations
Being wealthy
Being famous
Being physically attractive
Having satisfying, meaningful personal relationships
Making contributions to the community
Growing as individuals
Extrinsic
Intrinsic
Intrinsic vs extrinsic aspirations
Intrinsic aspirations are quite different from the extrinsic ones; they are satisfying in their own right.
Having strong aspiration for material success was associated with narcissism, anxiety, depression, and poorer social functioning
Strong aspirations for any of the intrinsic goals were positively associated with well-being
Extrinsic aspirations represent aspects of a false self
In developing an orientation toward external criteria for judging one's worth, people become particularly vulnerable to the forces of society
Individualism vs Autonomy
Individualism is about self-interest, about acting to achieve and acquire for yourself
Individualism is opposite to collectivism
Autonomy is about acting volitionally, with a sense of choice, flexibility, and personal freedom
Autonomy is opposite to being controlled
It's possible to be individualistic without being autonomous
Autonomy requires self-knowledge, so individualism can be autonomous only when accompanied by self-knowledge.
Self-knowledge
Begins with a relaxed attention to one's inner processes
Begins with genuine interest in oneself
Autonomy facilitates and is facilitated by self-knowledge
The Self in a Social World
Loosing touch with a true self
Development of true self requires autonomy support
Introjection facilitates the emergence of false self
Ego involvement
Undermines intrinsic motivation
Impairs learning and creativity
Diminishes performance on any task where flexible thinking and problem solving are required.
"If you dare to be fat, then you can be thin."
2 types of self-esteem
True self-esteem
Contingent self-esteem
Mutual dependence
When Society Beckons
How to promote a desirable behavior if the behavior is not intrinsically motivated?
Through Internalization
2 approaches to Internalization
That people are either passive or barbarous
That people are imbued with tendency and energy to grow and develop in accord with their psychological needs
2 quite different types of Internalization
Introjection
Integration
Possible outcomes of introjection vs integration
Rigid, dutiful compliance
Halfhearted adherence
Outright rebellion
People fail to have internalized values when their basic needs - for autonomy, competence, and relatedness - are not satisfied
Autonomy support is essential for promoting internalization and integration of the motivation for uninteresting, though important, activities
Providing a rationale
Acknowledging feelings
Minimizing pressures
Autonomy support != Permissiveness
The Inner Force of Development
Human development is not something done to the child
People develop through the process of organismic integration
Autonomy support is important for human development
The need for Relatedness
This is the third innate need
Doesn't contradict to Autonomy
Autonomy != Independence
Being Autonomous Amidst the Controls
Individual differences in temperament
Finding a Special Support
Individuals and Their Social World
To some extent, people influence the social world that influences them
People's expectations influence how they interpret a social environment
Individual Differences in Motivation
Promoting One's Own Development
Managing One's Own Experience
Regulating One's Emotions
Giving stimuli less threatening meanings
Ego-involvements make people a pawn to their emotions
Regulating One's Behavior
Allowing oneself to feel emotions and then deciding what to do with them
Emotions are an important messenger
The Use of Techniques
Motivation must come from within, not from techniques
Accepting Oneself
Promoting Healthy Behaviour
The Reasons for Change
Controlling (external or internal) reasons
Autonomous reasons
Personal choice to change
Accepting responsibility for own behavior and health
Taking genuine interest in own motivations
Noncompliance with Medical Regimens
This is a significant problem
Those who did a personal choice are more reliable in following medical prescriptions
Supporting Patient's Autonomy
The Biopsychosocial Approach
Doctor specialization made them focus on organs rather than people
The Biopsychosocial Approach looks at psychological and social factors instead
Responsibility and Autonomy Support
Training Providers to Be Autonomy Supportive
Autonomy-supportive interpersonal style encourages the integration of healthy values
How To Promote Autonomy
Deciding What to Do and How to Do It
It is possible that the decisions will be of higher quality than when manager decides alone
Choice enhances people's intrinsic motivation
There are, however, circumstances where it may be impractical or disadvantageous to offer choices
Being overly controlled in the past people may act as they don't want to have a choice; as if they want to be controlled.
Setting Autonomy-Supportive Limits
It is possible to have people set their own limits
Avoiding controlling language and acknowledging the resistance facilitate people's willingness to accept the limits
Providing the reason for limits
Making the limits as wide as possible and allowing choice within them will help keep people from feeling so restricted
Setting consequences of transgressing limits is an essential element for effective limit settting
Setting Goals and Evaluating Performance
To be most effective, goals need to be individualized and they need to be set so as to represent an optimal challenge
The best way to set goals is to involve the people in the process
People can also participate in evaluating their own performance
Administering Rewards and Recognition
When rewards or awards are used as a means of motivating people, they are likely to backfire
Recognizing the Obstacles
Some people have controlling personalities
Some people don't have skills necessary for practicing autonomy spport
When parents or managers feel more pressured, it's also more difficult for them to be autonomy supportive
Conclusion: The Meaning of Human Freedom
Human Freedom = To be truly autonomous
The true autonomy is accompanied by relatedness
True responsibility requires that people act autonomously