-
Introduction: Authority and Its Discontents
- Autonomous behavior vs. Controlled behavior
-
2 types of controlled behaviour
- Compliance
- Defiance
- Self-motivation vs. External motivation
-
Goals of the Book
- Examine the relation between autonomy and responsibility
- Reflect on the issue of promoting responsibility in an alienating world
-
Method of the Book
- Scientific, empiric approach
- Focusing on motivational processes
-
I'm Only in It for the Money
-
Behaviorist dogma
- Deliver a reward for a specific, identifiable behavior and do so as soon after the behavior as possible; focus on rewards rather than punishments; and be consistent in delivering the rewards.
- People are fundamentally passive and will respond only when the environment tempts them with the opportunity to get rewards or avoid punishments.
- It assumes that there is no inherent motivation to learn.
- Child's innate curiosity as a counter argument to Behaviorist dogma
-
Intrinsic motivation
- Refers to the process of doing an activity for its own sake, of doing an activity for the reward that is inherent in the activity itself.
- Being intrinsically motivates has to do with being wholly involved in the activity itself and not with reaching a goal.
-
Experiments on extrinsic rewards and negative effects of money rewards
- Undermined subjects' feelings of personal causation
- Turned play into work, and the player into a pawn
- People lose interest in activities
- People lose contact with their inner selves
-
The Need for Personal Autonomy
- Intrinsic need to feel a sense of personal autonomy or self-determination
-
Autonomy support increases intrinsic motivation
- Giving people choices about how to behave.
- When you provide people choice, it leaves them feeling as if you are responsive to them as individuals.
-
What decreases intrinsic motivation
- Threat
- Deadlines
- Imposed goals
- Surveillance
- Critical evaluations
- Competition
- Rewards (given with intention to control)
- Any occurrence that undermines feeling of autonomy decreases intrinsic motivation.
- Limit setting is still important for promoting responsibility
-
Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation
-
Instrumental reason
- Modern society evaluates everything in terms of its bottom-line yield, the cost-ratio benefit.
-
Extrinsic control all too often gets people focused only on the outcomes
- This leads to shortcuts that may be sad
- Worse learning
- Undermines intrinsic motivation
- Has detrimental effects on performance of any tasks that require creativity, conceptual understanding, or flexible problem solving.
-
Do people when they are intrinsically motivated also achieve great outcomes?
- Better results in learning
- Intrinsic motivation is associated with richer experience, better conceptual understanding, greater creativity, and improved problem solving, relative to external controls.
-
Pragmatic problems with relying on rewards and controls to motivate people
- You cannot easily go back
- People will all too likely take the shortest or quickest path
-
Engaging the World with a Sense of Competence
-
Meaningful contingencies, or behavior-outcome linkages - fundamental element necessary for motivation
- Without appropriate instrumentalities, there will not be productive, motivated behavior (but they are also the means for controlling behavior)
- There must be clarity about what behaviors are expected, and what outcomes will result from those instrumental behaviors
- People must also feel competent at instrumental behaviors
-
The need for Competency
- Feeling competent is important both for extrinsic motivation and for intrinsic motivation
- Competence is a second psychological need - beyond autonomy - that underlies intrinsically motivated behavior
- Optimal challenge
- Gaining competence is not enough though
-
Giving feedback
- Controlling praise decreases intrinsic motivation
-
Negative feedback is disastrous
- Start by asking what the other's thoughts about what happened
- People can typically be accurate in evaluating their own performance
-
When Society Corrupts
-
The American Dream as a motivating force
- Emphasis on materialism
-
Extrinsic and intrinsic life aspirations
- Being wealthy
- Being famous
- Being physically attractive
- Having satisfying, meaningful personal relationships
- Making contributions to the community
- Growing as individuals
- Extrinsic
- Intrinsic
-
Intrinsic vs extrinsic aspirations
- Intrinsic aspirations are quite different from the extrinsic ones; they are satisfying in their own right.
- Having strong aspiration for material success was associated with narcissism, anxiety, depression, and poorer social functioning
- Strong aspirations for any of the intrinsic goals were positively associated with well-being
- Extrinsic aspirations represent aspects of a false self
- In developing an orientation toward external criteria for judging one's worth, people become particularly vulnerable to the forces of society
-
Individualism vs Autonomy
- Individualism is about self-interest, about acting to achieve and acquire for yourself
- Individualism is opposite to collectivism
- Autonomy is about acting volitionally, with a sense of choice, flexibility, and personal freedom
- Autonomy is opposite to being controlled
- It's possible to be individualistic without being autonomous
- Autonomy requires self-knowledge, so individualism can be autonomous only when accompanied by self-knowledge.
-
Self-knowledge
- Begins with a relaxed attention to one's inner processes
- Begins with genuine interest in oneself
- Autonomy facilitates and is facilitated by self-knowledge
-
The Self in a Social World
- Loosing touch with a true self
- Development of true self requires autonomy support
- Introjection facilitates the emergence of false self
-
Ego involvement
- Undermines intrinsic motivation
- Impairs learning and creativity
- Diminishes performance on any task where flexible thinking and problem solving are required.
- "If you dare to be fat, then you can be thin."
-
2 types of self-esteem
- True self-esteem
- Contingent self-esteem
- Mutual dependence
-
When Society Beckons
-
How to promote a desirable behavior if the behavior is not intrinsically motivated?
- Through Internalization
-
2 approaches to Internalization
- That people are either passive or barbarous
- That people are imbued with tendency and energy to grow and develop in accord with their psychological needs
-
2 quite different types of Internalization
- Introjection
- Integration
-
Possible outcomes of introjection vs integration
- Rigid, dutiful compliance
- Halfhearted adherence
- Outright rebellion
- People fail to have internalized values when their basic needs - for autonomy, competence, and relatedness - are not satisfied
-
Autonomy support is essential for promoting internalization and integration of the motivation for uninteresting, though important, activities
- Providing a rationale
- Acknowledging feelings
- Minimizing pressures
- Autonomy support != Permissiveness
-
The Inner Force of Development
- Human development is not something done to the child
- People develop through the process of organismic integration
- Autonomy support is important for human development
-
The need for Relatedness
- This is the third innate need
- Doesn't contradict to Autonomy
- Autonomy != Independence
-
Being Autonomous Amidst the Controls
- Individual differences in temperament
- Finding a Special Support
-
Individuals and Their Social World
- To some extent, people influence the social world that influences them
- People's expectations influence how they interpret a social environment
- Individual Differences in Motivation
- Promoting One's Own Development
- Managing One's Own Experience
-
Regulating One's Emotions
- Giving stimuli less threatening meanings
- Ego-involvements make people a pawn to their emotions
-
Regulating One's Behavior
- Allowing oneself to feel emotions and then deciding what to do with them
- Emotions are an important messenger
-
The Use of Techniques
- Motivation must come from within, not from techniques
- Accepting Oneself
-
Promoting Healthy Behaviour
-
The Reasons for Change
- Controlling (external or internal) reasons
-
Autonomous reasons
- Personal choice to change
- Accepting responsibility for own behavior and health
- Taking genuine interest in own motivations
-
Noncompliance with Medical Regimens
- This is a significant problem
- Those who did a personal choice are more reliable in following medical prescriptions
- Supporting Patient's Autonomy
-
The Biopsychosocial Approach
- Doctor specialization made them focus on organs rather than people
- The Biopsychosocial Approach looks at psychological and social factors instead
- Responsibility and Autonomy Support
-
Training Providers to Be Autonomy Supportive
- Autonomy-supportive interpersonal style encourages the integration of healthy values
-
How To Promote Autonomy
-
Deciding What to Do and How to Do It
- It is possible that the decisions will be of higher quality than when manager decides alone
- Choice enhances people's intrinsic motivation
- There are, however, circumstances where it may be impractical or disadvantageous to offer choices
- Being overly controlled in the past people may act as they don't want to have a choice; as if they want to be controlled.
-
Setting Autonomy-Supportive Limits
- It is possible to have people set their own limits
- Avoiding controlling language and acknowledging the resistance facilitate people's willingness to accept the limits
- Providing the reason for limits
- Making the limits as wide as possible and allowing choice within them will help keep people from feeling so restricted
- Setting consequences of transgressing limits is an essential element for effective limit settting
-
Setting Goals and Evaluating Performance
- To be most effective, goals need to be individualized and they need to be set so as to represent an optimal challenge
- The best way to set goals is to involve the people in the process
- People can also participate in evaluating their own performance
-
Administering Rewards and Recognition
- When rewards or awards are used as a means of motivating people, they are likely to backfire
-
Recognizing the Obstacles
- Some people have controlling personalities
- Some people don't have skills necessary for practicing autonomy spport
- When parents or managers feel more pressured, it's also more difficult for them to be autonomy supportive
-
Conclusion: The Meaning of Human Freedom
- Human Freedom = To be truly autonomous
- The true autonomy is accompanied by relatedness
- True responsibility requires that people act autonomously