System 1 push - System 2 approve or not -ignore or approve
Override
System 1 push - System 2 restrain - block - override
Bat and a ball cost $1,10 in total; Bat cost $1 more that ball, how much the ball cost
$0,5
5 machines, 5 minutes, 5 widgets - how long 100 machines to make 100 widgets
5 minutes
lake - Lily pads - each days double in size 48 days to cover whole lake - how long to cover a half of the lake
47 days
cognitive reflection test - natural tendencies to involve system 2
Provoke intuitive answers - but wrong
Neglect
Similar to approval - but System 2 is unable to fulfill, occupied with something else
cognitive load task
Influenced
System 2 is influenced by System 1 - biases - "revenge" from System 1 block block of the desire - later...
mia measurement ??
Informed
System 2 is informed by System 1
Solo operation
System 2 works on its own
3: The role of heuristic in decision making
heuristic
simplification - reasonable good decisions
shortcut
trial-error
forms
anchoring and adjustments
numerical estimates
start with number you know and then make adjustments from that starting point
Problem
Inappropriate anchor
Under-adjust
to close to the starting point
Reason: influence to System 1 - interaction (biased)
availability
Reason: use subjecting thinking - influenced by System 1
estimate likelihood to happen
more vivid
Familiarity
overestimated
representativeness
likelihood to be part of some categories
Problems
Law od small numbers
small sample problem
Neglect the base rate
make some judgment parameter - complete out of proportion
Looks like someone with Phd
fit some stereotype
4: How habits make decisions easier
Habitual behaviour
General tendencies to respond to particular ques in a particular ways - simplifying decision making
Que - trigger: stimulus - response
habitual (environment) trigger
even nothingness
Reword
instant reword - important;
Shifting - to automatic decision
System 2 - train System 1 to make some tasks, and release System 2 from doing it
5: Self regulations and choices
ego resource - executive resource
part of System 2
control room of the brain
theoretical constructs - not particular part of the brainf
self regulatory functions related to
attention controll
emotion regulation
impulse override
behaviour modification
two ways of depletion effect decision making
resources - out of fuel - stop working
changes the decision that we make
can cause depletion of the resources
after self-regulatory decision - we are low with resources for other self-regulator behaviour
switching mindsets - also consume executive resource
require selfcontrol
roles
motion in action - fast eliminating strategy
comparing features strategy
System 2 try to override System 1
1-4: consuming ego resources
one unitary container of self regulation resources
6: The value curve and human decisions
Diagram - curve
S shaped
Describe how object value is transformed to subject value
Properties how the mind transform the value
The curve has a reference point at the origin - zero point of the curve
valuation is always in relation to something else
reference point is fluid - can be anywhere - and influence on valuation
The curve is characterised by diminished sensitivity - bending toward horizontal axis, as the get further from zero point
Less and less sensitive to changes to objective value... (objective value increases, but we do not feel the same increase in feelings about it).
more we have - less sensitive to it we are
2:1 ratio
The curve is kinked at the zero point
people are much more sensitive to looses, than to winnings - loose $10 is much more painful than winning $10 is good
7: Emotional influences on decision making
Social isolation - prefer more riskier behaviour
money - compensation to loneliness
Cognitive machinery
hot cognition
emotions
distraction in decision making
absence of emotion does not lead to better decision making
Vital - necessary in decision making - not only distraction
appraisal tendency framework
specific emotional states (not positive or negative)
metrics of 6 dimensions (attributes)
How (level of influence) emotions influence on decision making process
Certainty
Pleasantness
Attentional activity
Anticipated effort
Personal control
Responsibility
Angry and Happiness - according to this model can produce similar decisions - shared attributes are: Certainty, Personal control
Example
Hi level of confidence
Disgust
Certainty
Happiness
Certainty
Lo level of confidence
Fear
Un-certainty
Hope
Un-certainty
more confident to prediction
less confident to prediction
cold cognition
8: How goals guides our decisions
motivation - control panel
Goals: direct our cognitive machinery in specific direction
Tension concept
current states
Representation of
Desires
End states
Goal hierarchy
Maslow's goals hierarchy - not correct, but can be used as framework
types
intrinsic
internal reword or punishment
extrinsic
external reword or punishment
used to induce intrinsic motivation, but this is not possible (or, not and - extrinsic kill intrinsic)
Goal pursuit
progress - make to work harder - motivate us
goal gradient hypothesis
faster - near / closer reword
after goal is achieved and reward consumed - behaviour reset to initial and start again
Progress - sometime - make to make less harder - less pressure
coloring weight distance - chocolate or apple experiment
as much concrete goal is - difference in behaviour - vry concrete - progress will motivate us, not very concrete - no real praise - softer goal - expect licensing
9: Reason based choices
Choose option - average option and enriched option (extreme positive and extreme negative - advantages and disadvantages): Enriched will be chosen - to award and to deny
overweighing information
when we are choosing - related to question - we tend to overestimate the importance of information - some not very important become important
bed reasons
golf umbrella example - small gift that we do not need can lead to avoiding purchase
different reasons on time of choice (susyem 2), then later day to day reasons (system1)
generating a reason - shift from system 1 to system 2
influence on choice and make us less satisfied with the choice after a some time
10: Mental accounting as a factor in decision
people categorise money according to intended use
the same money - categorised differently
loosed ticket - pay twice for same
loosed money - pay ticket once, and loose once - more willing to pay
envelops - packages
one event vs multiple smaller events
strongly react on multiple events
diminished sensitivity
fixed rate vs variable rates
effects
gains - better impact
segragated
loses - less impact
aggregates
couple pain
payment in rates in advance - at the time for pleasure - no distractions with pain of loses
In casino - pain of buying chips - decoupled from enjoying the gambling
fixed rate vs variable rates
fixed rate preferred - aggregate the looses
cache vs cards
cache - immediately pain
card - aggregated pain and decoupled form purchase
advices
Use partitions - even simple envelops
segment pleasures
combine pains
decouple a pain of payment from pleasure of consumption
11: The role of mind-sets in decision making
reaction to stimulation is not instantaneous - serious of stages
Mental preparatory stage - mindset
anticipate the stimulations that will come
one of use of mindset: implication of culture
changeable
selfconstrual - self definition
we think about ourself one way, or another
independent
Western culture
interdependent
Eastern culture
Olimpic open ceremony - in China example
rubicon model
any action - series of stages, take in consideration two stages - immediately before, and after the decision - different set of cognitive problems - different mind-sets
deliberative: goal setting stage: after this stage "rubicon" is crossed
desires transforms to the goals
evaluation, discover, searching for possibilities: open-mindedness
Implemental: Planning stage: decision is made and we need to start making plans to put it into action (how, when and where...)
concrete, what, when, how - Implementation mode: commitment - focused: close minded mindset
biased toward decision
Experiment - memory test; making the end of story
12: How consistency drives decisions
threat, problem and powerful desire and motive - consistency
sources
coherence: behavior in consistency with believes
discrepancy
attitude strength
most important in predict behaviour...
attitude valence (how much you like on hate, believe or not believe)
reinforcement: consistency of believes over time
Even intensifies over time
example: attitude polarization
believes after balanced prove (some contra your believes) - believes become more extreme
Confirmation bias: Homogenies groups eliminate interest for contra arguments and proves (bias 1); one of three participant with different opinion - bias become negative (bias -0,5), means participant seek for different opinions -> reinforcement with "devil advocate" reduce reinforcement bias bit not eliminate it.
habit: behaviour - consistent with previous behaviour - action lead to consistent action
self perception: believes conform to be consistent with behaviors
cognitive dissonance
change believes to be consistent with actions which will not be changed: behaviour drive believe
Symbolic self-complition
fool ourselves - only when someone is insecure of ourselves: empowered self image by external symbols
13: social influences on decision making
choices and decisions influenced by other people
compliance professional
Influence - book
Principles
Reciprocation
receive something - feel obligation to return in a kind way
gift - increase response, but exchange money for time- not.
reciprocal concessions
after initial rejection - small request seems reasonable and acceptable
requester is moved from his initial position, so you can too
Social proof
Social norms - pear pressure
every other doing this
normalize behaviour
phobia to tolerance
Authority
compliance to authority
even "small" authority
Necessary conditions
Gift must be understood as a gift something un-ordinary and not an obligation
gift must seem sincere
14: non - conciseness influences on decision making
terms
subliminal stimuli - below the level of conciseness
real - but not powerful effect
supraliminal stimuli - within the level of conciseness
conciseness influence
non-conciseness influence
description
goal activation
latent goals - activated
cold - activate temperature - not only body, emotions also
bed thoughts (morally dirty): activate desire to clean ourself
conditions
subliminal influence - conditioning - but only to neutral believes
15: Evolutionary review of decision making
"just so" explanation - relation between past and present - not always scientific
fact
machinery including system 1 and system 2- result of evolution
evolution shapes set of motives and drives
influences
random variation
adaptive
mal - adaption
natural selection
Sexual selection
evolutionary goals that affect individual decision making
non-conciseness
self-protection -natural
disease avoidance - natural
affiliation - both
status - both
maid acquisition - sexual
maid retention - sexual
kin care - sexual
sub-selfs present at the same time
16: Regulatory focus and decision making
Motives: seek pleasure and avoid pain
old theory
Regulatory focus: way you motivate yourself
motivations - work hard reason:
potential recognition - promotion
gain
To obtain job security
non loses
to not be fired
avoid loses
getting stuck, left behind
avoid non gain
Regulatory focus - chronical but easy to shift around
culture, parents style - security, promotional
Approach motivation (top half of vertical line)
Avoidance motivation (bottom half of vertical line)
Promotion orientation (left side of horizontal lines)
Preventional orientation (right side of horizontal bar)
regulatory fit
go pursuit (težiti)
positive feedback
motivate promotional types
work harder - achieving
de-motivate preventional types
relaxation - enough secure
persuasion (nagovarati)
promotion types - gain feels - more persuasive
Preventional types - arguments about avoiding looses - more persuading
decision making
Not based on outcomes, then on probability estimates
when making estimates - terminology borrowed from signal theory: 4 possible outcomes
score a hit
you guess and you ar right
Promotion - maximize right hits
error of omission
you miss a chance - everybody enjoyed, and you stayed at home
Promotion - avoiding errors of omission
correct rejection
you refuse to go - and it was right decision because nobody enjoyed
Prevention - maximize correct rejection
error of commission
you decide to go and it was miserable - you made wrong choice
Prevention - minimize error of commission
Quadrants
upper left: seeking a gain
upper right: seeking non loses - security
bottom left: avoid non gains, avoid be un-fulfilled, or be sad
bottom right: avoid losses, reduce anxiety
17: Decision rules
Decision in situation without obvious winner (choices which is impossible to compare)
set of rules for decision making
amount of information processed
some as many as possible, others only few key information
order of gathering information
attribute to attribute from each option or all attributes from first option then all from other option
How they weight information
compensatory: trade off between options - good in trade off with some bed attribute value; or non-compensatory: if option fail in some attribute - that is it - over, finished.
How effort-full and accurate they appear to be
effortless, but produce errors - on one side of spectrum and care in consideration bit very accurate - other side of spectrum
Specific rules derived from basic rules
weighted additive rule
which attribute and how much important each attribute is
difficult and slow
most accurate
elimination by aspects
strategically drop options from consideration - one by one; must know which attribute is most important to us - order - ranking (not weighting)
different outcome in contrast to weighted additive rule - less accurate
easier to make decision - reason for less accuracy
differnt order of processing information
non-compensatory
satisficing: satisfy and suffice
to find first good enough option: must know importance of attributes (like elimination by aspects) but decision stops after first attribute which satisfy our demand.
less demanding
in-consisting choices - dependent on order
Important: person with consisting preferences - can make totaly different decision related to applied rules - decision strategy
18: How context influences choices
immediate environment within decision has to be make
decoy effect (attraction effect)
proven in lab - numerically presented, but in real life - significate less effective
Third option influence on selection between first two: car C provide a reason to buy car B - asymmetrically dominated (B dominated C) - objectively irrelevant - but still big influence
the compromise effect
extremes aversion - avoid extremes
not worst, even not the best - reason for decision
not to choose - "not choice" option available
forced choice scenario - when choosing between options (like a or b)
easy to articulate options - prefer
if "not to choose" options: holistic approach - not attribute to attribute, instead option to option - quality meters
Music
energetic
calm
Place
19: How framing effects guides decision
prisoners dilemma
thinking of a teem - different then thinking separately
wall street game
community game
framing effect - way how information are communicated
Types of framing
status quo framing
preference to default - status quo option
avoidance to make active decision to change
game loss framing
losses most painful
experiment - change people risk preferences
gains - risk averse
losses - hate sure loss - willing to risk
opportunity cost neglect
not informative fact - change preferences
opportunity cost - is your choice better than something else - if yes - choose it.
better stereo or cheaper stereo and possibilities to buy some CD's - we know that lower price left money for other use - but framing options in this way - make us prefer second option
refocus on loses
20: Role of memory in decisions
memory: internal - raw material: construct choice set
stored
repeteated
dueled upon
unusual
Personal relevant
tied to preexisted memory structure
humor
music
retrieved
memory organization (indexed) influence on retrieval
memory cue
21: Assortments, variety and choices
example: jam choice test - 6 or 24 kind of jams: 40% / 60% stops - 30% / 3% redeem coupon - means: large number of choices - harder to choose
choice overload
large choice options - de-motivated
change reference point (less satisfied with choice)
easier to find perfect wife in small town - than in large town: when find someone - most be someone better
when more choices are better
articulated ideal point (hypothetical ideal choice)
When people know exactly what thew want - not very often - when before decision articulate ideal point
close enough to your ideal point
when we are not sure where we will find what we are looking for - prefers large choice options - but problem of selecting will occur later
if both choice sets (both stores, both retired plans) are equally attractive - recommended, or with same recension level - prefers to larger choices diminish
tools for making selection (hierarchy of small numbers of choices)
22: How evaluability effects decisions
hard to evaluate something without reference point - we tent to make decision related to even less important attribute, but referenced to some known value (reference point)
important observations
attributes differs in evaluability
is it clear reference point - evaluation upon - frame of reference - need expertise for understanding reference
work-around
relative evaluation - side by side
joint evaluation - hi quality external reference point
without refference point - decision upon easier evaluated attribute
social refference
relative to other people
relative to average user..
importance of attribute is function of evaluability
easy evaluate - most important
hard to evaluate - less important in making decision
23: Halo effects and choices
influence of higher order impressions (taste less important then brand - coca-colla)
one impression influence on whole range of attributes
Halo effects - fill the gaps - if you do not have all information - you will produce them according to impression that you have
higher order impressions is useful if is very detailed
if not - decision is biased upon (first info about someone - without solid reference point):
The same - purchase: price evaluation without reference point - look of the store
psychical attraction
more intelligent
kind
friendly
trustworthy
successful
happier
24: 4 R's of decision making
Decisoins: granular and complex theory - not easy to understand
stack on deck
high causal density phenomena
a lot of potential causes of decisions
Rules
Reference point matter
many theorises is based on reference point
pay 5% higher price for use card
or pay 5% discount to pay in cache
if there are not reference point - which work-around is used
hi-lo
...
Reasons matter
picking decision that can bi justifies to others and to themselves
reasons do not have to be good or logical
if there are not clear superior option - any reason can be reason for choice
if promotion offer plate - but I do not need a plate - than this can be reason to refuse that offer
Resources (cognitive) matter
People has limited cognitive resources
decision - function of available resources
fast, easy
if we are exhausting, or distracted
slow, detailed
people developed coping strategy - because resource are limited
strategic about how we spend precious resources
cognitive misers
satisficing rules
habitual response
availability heuristic
Replacement
difficult task (question) replaced with easy one (question)
used in different theories and different situations
making estimates is complicated and difficult
instead people use availability heuristic
when buying flood insurance, for example: how hard for me is to remember some situations - instead to analyse all possibilities
difficult problem replaced with easy one
Which presidential candidate will better handle international crisis related to refugies
instead: which candidate will be better for drinking bear with or which candidate look more presidential
people try to find a reason to choose and reject - depend on a question