-
1. Key concepts
-
1. What is Deep Learning (DL)?
- Aims to imitate human thought process via data analysis and algorithms called artificial neural networks
-
2. How is Dynamic Contrast-Enhanced Magnetic Resonance Imaging (DCE-MRI) used for breast cancer diagnostics?
- 1. Highly sensitive (80%) test used for detecting breast cancer
-
2. DCE-MRI results can be classified into 6 distinct categories within a BI-RADS system.
- Type 1 = Negative
- Type 2 = Benign finding
- Type 3 = Probably benign finding
-
Type 4 = Suspicious abnormality
- MUST DO BIOPSY
- Type 5 = Malignant
- Type 6 = Already proven to have been malignant
-
2. What is the current issue?
-
Positive Predictive Value (PPV) of biopsy results of women diagnosed with BI-RADS type 4 range from 19.6% to 35.7%
-
In other words, for every malignant biopsy, 2-4 other biopsy findings are benign
-
These benign results
- Cause stress & patient workup!!
- Result in unnecessary biopsies!!
-
3. How can DL solve this current issue?
-
1. Improve the MRI specificity
- Reduce the number of false positives
- Minimize unnecessary biopsies
- Reduce patient workup
- 2. Improve clinical impact by facilitating the translation from results to intervention
-
4. Testing Methods
- 1. Evaluating DL-MRI performance by comparing it with radiologists' diagnostics using AUROC curves
-
2. Using Decision Analysis Curve (DCA) to determine clinical utility impact on decision-making
- Example: Is it possible to downgrade a patient from BI-RADS 4 to BI-RADS 3 and, thus, reduce unnecessary biopsies?
-
4.1 Evaluating DL-MRI performance using AUROC curves
- TPR (sensitivity) vs FPR (1-specificity)
- DL-MRI is either just as good or better than radiologists' diagnostics.
-
4.2 Using DCA to determine clinical utility impact
-
Is it possible to downgrade a patient from BI-RADS 4 to BI-RADS 3?
-
Standard net benefit
- % of unnecessary biopsies avoided
-
Decision threshold
- Variable according to threshold probabilities and to doctor/patient preferences
- Even at low decision thresholds, DL-MRI proves to be much more effective than a biopsy all intervention
-
5. Limitations to this study?
-
1. No investigation on how DL-MRI makes its decisions.
- DL-MRI doesn't specify what specific part of the image influenced their prediction
- 2. No cost-effective analysis on benefits of DL-MRI
-
6. Conclusion
- 1. DL-MRI possesses diagnostic accuracy equivalent to radiologist experts
- 2. Improves clinical impact utility via personalized patient management