-
Conflict
-
Stages
-
perceived conflict
- Merger - gutted MS executives
- "Handshake deal" for Purcell to hand reigns back to Mack never came to pass, Mack left
-
Failed mergers with 3 large banks
- failure to bridge gaps between MS and Dean Witter
-
felt conflict
- Wachovia merger - lines were drawn between Purcell and Exec Mgmt
- Strategic plan failed to be agreed on
-
manifest conflict
- Retail blamed Inv bankers for increasing risk
- Inv Bankers blamed retail for slide
- Purcell left key executives off org chart
- Public attacks from G8 on Purcell's lack of strategic planning
-
Causes
-
Pooled interdependence
- Investment banking
- Retail
-
Perceptual differences
-
status incongruence
- MS group felt Dean Whitter Executives "won" in merger
-
difference perspectives
- Risk vs. Return; Investments vs. Retail
-
Changes between groups
-
Distorted Perceptions
- Lack of effective leadership
-
Negative Stereotyping
- "Proving" poor leadership through repeated failures
-
Decreased Communications
- Complete breakdown in communication
-
Failed Approaches
-
Dominating
-
Purcell
- minimal focus on meeting other groups concerns
- Purcell had advantage of power
- Chose only those who supported him
-
G8
- Used public attacks to force resignation
-
alter the organizational structure
- Was really a dominating tactic
-
New Approaches
-
Problem Solving (integrating/collaborating)
- Very difficult
- Maximum focus on both groups' concerns
- Make each group responsible for resolving some parts of the conflict
-
Bring in new people
- Mistrust of Zoe Cruz is an issue; she will have to work with others
-
Questions
- Describe conflict between Purcell & G8; functional or dysfunctional & why?
- What specific changes occurred between the two groups as a result of unresolved conflict?
- Which conflict resolution approaches did Purcell use & why weren't they effective?
- Which approaches should Mack use to resolve G8 demands & other executives?
-
Resources
- Mack plans to step down, early 2010
- Bloomberg 9/2009
- John Mack Biography
- Zoe Cruz leaves