- These can exist in combinations, resulting in 4 possibilities
-
When to use the case study method
- Different research methods serve complimentary functions
-
2 situations for a case study
- descriptive questions (what happened?) or explanatory question (how or why did something happen?)
-
In depth or first-hand understanding of a particular situation
- Natural settings
-
examples given
- good highschool principle
- everyday life in a residential school
-
Always ask: "What is the "case" (unit if analysis)
-
Related subtopics?
-
school, family, friends (if case is the student)
- "key contextual conditions"
-
Examples of possible case studies
- Non english student in school vs out of school
- teachers use of groups
- violence prevention program
- performance improving schools
- school-business partnership and its effect
- school choice policy
-
An essential skill for case study investigators
- Must be able to collect data and analyze data at the same time
- Must be able to separate out your own opinion, because you may have to ask a question that you already think you know the answer to
-
Three basic steps in designing case studies
-
First step: DEFINE
- You may be able to redefine based on preliminary data
-
Second step
- Single case or multiple case?
- Holistic or embedded within holistic?
- Single case and multiple case are interesting because multiple cases could be seen as replications, contrasting comparisons, or variations
-
Theory development
- If you're new, do it
- If you're experienced you may be able to find a "break the mold" case
-
Choosing specific persons, groups or sites to be your case
- Thinking of the case and actually picking the group are very different
- Do not represent formal sample from larger population
- No statistical inference
-
generalizing from case studies
- substantive topics
- issues of interest
-
logical inferences
- analytic generalizations
- Could be an extreme or unique case
- Case study screening procedure
-
Multiple case study design ALSO has cross-case issues
- confirmatory?
- contrasting?
- theoretically diverse?
-
3 + cases?
- geographic, ethnic, size, and other variation
-
No case is a control for another case
- No treatments occur. No control.
-
Multiple case study design makes you look stronger
- Comparative data exists
-
Varieties of sources of case study data
-
multiple sources of evidence
- triangulation
-
Commons sources of evidence in doing case studies
- Docs
- Archival records
- Interviews
- Direct observation
- Participant observation
- Physical artifacts
- It's important to keep up on the most recent data collection instruments
- Qualitative and quantitative are both possible
-
Do not mix data and interpretation
- Keep a separate interpretive narrative
-
Ways of analyzing case study data
- Data do not always speak for themselves
-
analysis methods may come from your original question
-
Stipulate a pattern of findings
- pattern matching
- explanation building
- time-series analysis
- logic models
- cross-case synthesis
-
Case studies are not always so linear, with data, and then analysis.
- Sometimes these sections can happen throughout the document
- You look stronger if you incorporate rival explanations or alternative perspectives
-
Composing case study reports
- No set standard way
- You must like writing!
-
For further discussion
-
Five common worries in using the case study method
- How do I know if I should use the case study method to do my study?
- How should I select the case to be studied?
- I am studying a school. What is my case: Is it the teachers? The reading program? The whole school?
- How much time and effort should I devote to collecting the case study data? How do I know whether I'm finished collecting the data?
- How do I start analyzing my case study?