Capacity
>18 years old
Mental capacity
Certainty of intention
Equity looks to intent rather than form
Paul v Constance
Conduct
Words
Trust words impose a binding duty on trustee
Precatory words don't create a trust
Re Adams and Kensington Vestry
Certainty of subject matter
Certainty of beneficial interest
Must be
Defined
Objective formula given
Re Golay
reasonable income
Trustees to determine
Discretionary trusts
Certainty of object
Applies to gifts and trusts
Charitable trusts are an exception
Class of objects
Fixed trust
Complete list
IRC v Broadway Cottages
Must be possible to draw up a comprehensive list of every beneficiary or will fail
Conceptual certainty
Clear concepts to describe beneficiaries
Evidential certainty
Must be possible to identify each and every member of the class
Powers of Appointment
Authority to deal with property in some way
Doesn't have to be exercised
Must at least consider whether to exercise it. Own judgment
Turner v Turner
Creates a fiduciary duty
Re Hay Settlement
Must consider periodically whether to exercise power or not
Must consider range of objects of power
Must consider appropriateness of individual appointments
Must not act capriciously
Re Manistry's Settlement
Ascertain existence from person's intention and words used
e.g. 'may'
Includes gifts in appointment
If no appoint made
Resulting trust back to settlor's estate
Given Postulent Test
If it can be said with certainty whether any given individual is, or is not a member of the class of objects .
Re Gestetner's/ Re Gulbenkian's Settlement
Discretionary trusts
Given postulent test
McPhail v Doulton (Main)
Re Baden
Stamp LJ
Yes or no box
'Don't Know' Box
Sachs LJ
Conceptual certainty is essential
Megaw LJ
If substantial number can prove themselves to be within the class- would stand as trust
Beneficiary Principle
Trust must be for benefit of ascertainable beneficiaries
Morice v Bishop of Durham
Failed trust
Re Shaw
Exceptions
Charitable
Re Dean
Re Hooper
Constitution
Settlor declares self trustee
Trust is automatically constituted
T Choithram v Pagrani
Lifetime trust by transfer
Legal estate in land
Transferred by deed
S52 LPA 1925
see Mascall v Mascall
Chattels
Delivery
Deed of transfer
Jaffa v Taylor Gallery
Company shares
Private (inside crest)
delivery of signed stock transfer form and share certificate to trustee
Sent to be registered
Public (outside crest)
Recorded immediately
No need for form
Equitable interest under trust
Signed written disposition
S53(1)(c) LPA 1925
Will trust
Property vests in PRs
Invariably constituted
Equity will not assisted a volunteer (by interpreting a failed gift as a trust)- Milroy v Lord
Every effort test
Re Rose
Unconscionable to revoke
Pennington v Waine
Strong v Bird
D intends to make a gift but is invalid and fails to comply with formalities to transfer legal title
Intention must be to make immediate gift
Re Freeland
"As soon as I can get (the car) on the road"
Intention must remain unchanged until dying
D dies and donee is appointed donor's executive. Vests in donee and gift perfected
Formalities
Lifetime Trust
Trust over personalty
No formalities
If using trustee. Must transfer property to constitute trust
Must use correct formalities
If declares self as trustee, is disposing of subsisting equitable interest
S53(1)(C) LPA 1925
Signed and in writing
Trust over land
S53(1)(B) LPA 1925
Signed by settlor
Evidence in writing
Settlor's equitable interest
If seperate from legal title
S53(1)(C)
Can direct trustee of own interest to hold trust property on trust for another
Grey v IRC
Oral declaration was a disposition of interest
BUT failed S53(1)(C) formalities
If transfers legal and equitable interests at same time
Vandervell v IRC
S53(1)(C) won't apply
Will
Must be in writing
AND signed by testator
AND signed by two witnesses
Perpetuities
Trusts created prior to 6th April 2010
80 years
Trusts created prior after PAA 2009
125 years
Certainty of trust property
Hunter v Moss
Shares were indistinguishable so no need to segregate
Re London Wine Company
Must be possible to identify and segregate specific property
Chattels- Wine