- "The greatest and most distinctive achievement
performed by Englishmen in the field of jurisprudence"
Maitland
-
Authorities
-
Earl of Oxford's Case (1615)
- Conflict of Common Law & Chancery Courts resolved
-
Kingsnorth v Tizzard (1986)
- Separated Husband claimed to be single: Bank under Constructive Notice
-
Judicature Act 1873 s25(11)
- "Where (conflict)...rules of equity shall prevail"
-
Equity
-
Effects
-
Contract
- Formation creates equitable interest
-
Land Transfer
- Formally deficient deed
-
Remedies
- Specific Performance
- Injunctions
-
Separate Property
Interests
- Legal
- Equitable
-
Parallel System
- King > Lord Chancellor > Courts of Chancery
-
Based on 'Equity'
- Remedy for unconscionable acts
- "Equity varies with the length of the Chancellor's foot"
John Selden (C17)
-
Conflict
-
Earl of Oxford's case (1615)
- Equity should prevail (Sir Frances Bacon (Att. General)
-
Judicature Acts 1873/5
- "Where (conflict)...rules of equity shall prevail" s25(11) Jud Act 1873
-
'Maxims' (12-20)
- Equity will not suffer a wrong to be without a remedy
- Equity regards done what ought to be done
- Equity delights in equality
-
Equity aids the vigilant
- Or...delay defeats equity
-
One who seeks equity must do equity
- Or... must come with clean hands
- Equity acts in personam
- Equity does not require an idle gesture
- Equity follows the law
- First in time, first in right
-
Trusts
-
Parties
-
Settlor
- Cannot enforce the trust!
-
Trustee(s)
- Fiduciary duty
Must act in 'good faith'
- Duties specific to Trust
-
Beneficiary
- "The trust's policeman"
-
Controversy: are interests
personal or proprietary?
- Interests linked to property
- Interests vanish if property destroyed
- Rights created peacemeal
- Some beneficiaries can
demand property (Bare trust)
- Enforcable against 3rd parties
- Become new trustees
- Ability to trace assets
- Proprietary claim
on trustees' bankruptcy
- Common View: Proprietary
-
Common Uses
-
Wealth Management
- e.g. Wills
-
Collective Investments
- e.g. Unit Trusts
- Clubs/Societies
-
Charities
- Purpose Trusts
-
Creation
- Explicit
-
Resulting
- Default return to settlor
-
Constructive
- e.g. solicitor holding
client's money
-
Essential Elements
- Trustee(s)
- Property
- Duty (Fiduciary)
-
Browne-Wilkinson LJ
- Westdeuche Landsbank v Islington (1996)
-
Bone Fide Purchaser Rule
- "Equity's Darling"
- Allows property to be safely transferred
-
Exception to transfer of equitable duties if
property is transferred IN BREECH of trust
- Purchaser takes legal estate
free from equitable duties
-
ONLY IF: they are "bone fide purchaser
for value without notice"
- 1. Bone fide: no fraud
- 2. Purchaser: transfer by act of parties
- Includes 'pro tanto' purchase of lease
- 3. For value: consideration
- 4. Legal estate passed:
from trustee, not beneficiary
- 5. Without notice: actual or constructive
- Kingsnorth v Tizzard (1986)
- Flexible Structure