-
MISC.
- Ethics -> Agreed system of moral codes.
- Morality -> Individuals moral code.
-
Three main types of ethics
-
1) Descriptive ethics -> Describes morality of people
- Not covered
-
2) Meta-ethics -> Studies of language; what people mean.
- Covered in year 13
-
3) Normative-ethics -> How people decide right from wrong.
- Covered in year 12
-
Ethical Theories
-
Views of the good
- Objective -> The view that good and bad exists as a matter of fact.
Regardless of peoples opinions.
- Subjective -> The view that good and bad is a matter of opinions.
NO fact of the matter
-
Relatism
- Relatism -> View that acts are right or wrong relative to the
Situation or people involved and its consequences.
- Relativists ->Acts would vary depending on the situation.
- Cultural Relatism ->Each society develops its own right or wrong moral laws
- Subjective Relatism -> Each individual creates their own sense of right or wrong
-
Absolutism
- Absolutists -> Acts are always right or wrong.
- Absolutism -> Acts are right or wrong in themselves.
-
Deontological
-
Deontological ethics
- Kant-> Categorical imperatives
- Aquinas-> Natural law
- Deontological -> Approach to ethics that suggests that an action is right if it conforms to a set of rules.
-> Involving doing your DUTY
-> Absolutist approach to ethics
-
Teleological
-
Teleological ethics
- Fletcher -> Situationism
- Bentham/Mill -> Utilitarian
- Teleological -> Consequentialist approach to ethics
-> An action is right if given that the situation results in the best possible outcome.
-> Relativist approach to ethics
-
Situationism
- Relativist and Teleological approach to decision making
-
The Middle Ground (3 approaches)
- Legalistic -> fixed moral rules and regulations ALWAYS be obeyed
- Antinomianism -> Abandonment of ALL rules purely spontaneous and casual.(REJECTED by fletcher)
- Situaltionism -> Principles and rules of society and culture but sets them aside in the name of 'love'
-
Four presuppositions of situationsim
- Pragmatism -> Action must be practical and work in achieving the desired end (love).
- Relativism -> Acts would vary depending on the situation.
- Positivism -> Love is the most important criteria of all
- Personalism -> People, not rules, are put first
-
Utilitarianism
-
Bentham
-
Pleasure and pain
- Hedonistic view
- Maximise pleasure, Minimise pain.
-
Priniciple of utility
- An act is right if it produces the greatest good for the greatest number
-
Hedonic calculus
- Measures and weighs up Pleasure and Pain as a result of an action.
- No-one more important than anyone else
-
Calculus made up of seven points
- Intensity of the pleasure (how strong the pleasure is)
- Duration of the pleasure (how long will the pleasure last)
- Certainty of the pleasure(how sure can you be the pleasure will arrive)
- Propinquity or Remoteness of the pleasure (how close is the pleasure)
- Fecundity of the pleasure (will more pleasure be followed)
- Purity of the pleasure (produce only pleasure)
- Extent of the pleasure ( number of people affected by the action)
- Act utilitarianism ->Principle of utilitarianism to be applied in each situation.
-
Mill
-
Higher and Lower pleasures
- qualitative approach
-
Higher pleasures -> Mental/ Intellectual pleasures
- Religion
- Philosophy
- Reading poetry
- Appreicating art
- Listening to music
-
Lower pleasures -> Physical/Bodily pleasures
- Eating
- Drinking
- Sleep
- Sex
-
Rule utilitarianism
- Strong rule utilitarianism -> once a rule has been derived for the community they must never be broken
- Weak rule utilitarianism -> Generally accepted rules there may still be situations as to where the greatest good for the greatest number can still be reached
-
Singer
-
Preference utilitarianism
- NOT hedonistic
-
Questions often asked when deciding what is the best out come for the situation
- what is my preference in the situation?
- What is in my own interest?
- What outcome would i prefer ?
- It has to still obey the greatest good for the greatest number
- Choose the action that gives the best possible outcome for those concerned. Not what produces the most pleasure.
- Our own preference cannot count for more than the preference of others
-
Medical Ethics 1
-
Abortion and Rights to a child
-
Sanctitcy of life
- ALL life is sacred
-
Strong sanctity of life
- 'So God created humankind in his image'
- Blessed by God
- Given dominionship over world
-
Weak sanctity of life
-
Extraordinary means as a justification of killing
- Applies the Christian principle of love and compassion
-
Justified Abortion
- Double Effect (Save mothers life but means Aborting the foetus)
-
Following 'Defend the Innocent' Primary Precept
- You cannot Abort a child as it cannot defend for its self or use reason
-
Quality of life
-
Disability in the foetus
- They can be Aborted if screened and found to be disabled (physical or mental handicaps)
- Some people dislike this as the "disabled" child might live a full and loving life despite of the disability
- If every one did this there would be no "disabilities " in the human race
-
Equality and Disability
- People who are disables should not be discriminated against in any way
- Allow disabled people to live a full life
-
Pro-choice / Pro-life
-
Pro-choice
- Mothers choice in abortion
- The people involved concern
-
Pro-life
- Against Abortion
- wants child to be born
- Rights to a child
-
Genetic Engineering
-
Crops
- A major benifit is the reduction in the use of fertilizers , herbicides and pesticides
-
We can modify the DNA of plants
- To create a healthy yield and reduce pesticides
-
Farmers buy into a circle of dependency
- The multinational companies are selling seeds and fertilizers to the farmers
- The farmers soil becomes conditioned to a certain pesticide , herbicide and fertilizers
- Hostility to the Genetic modification of crops, described as 'Frankenstein - Food'
-
Animals
- We can grow 'ears' on rats
- Similar to GM crops (above)
-
Humans
-
Germ line
-
Sperm or eggs, are modified by the introduction of functional genes, which are integrated into their genomes
- Highly effective in counteracting genetic disorders and hereditary diseases
-
Stomatic cells
- Modifications and effects will be restricted to the individual patient only, and will not be inherited by the patients offspring or later generations
-
Stem Cells
-
They can be specialised into any other cell
- Can be obtained from
- Umbilical cord (The blood)
- Adults(From tissues)
-
Saviour Siblings
-
They are younger siblings created to save / improve the standard of living for the elder sibling
- Laws stop people having Saviour Siblings
- Save the life of the parents
- Harvest organs
- Genetically identical to the elder sibling
- Tissue type match
- Uses a lot of embryos (IVF will be needed)
-
Clones
-
Reproductive Cloning
- The genetic duplication of an existing organism especially by transferring the nucleus of a somatic cell of the organism into an enucleated cell
-
Therapeutic cloning
- Stem cells from (typically) skin cells, and use those cells to grow tissue that are a perfect genetic match for the patient
-
Abortion and Rights to a child
-
Sanctitcy of life
- ALL life is sacred
-
Strong sanctity of life
- 'So God created humankind in his image'
- Blessed by God
- Given dominionship over world
-
Weak sanctity of life
-
Extraordinary means as a justification of killing
- Applies the Christian principle of love and compassion
-
Justified Abortion
- Double Effect (Save mothers life but means Aborting the foetus)
-
Following 'Defend the Innocent' Primary Precept
- You cannot Abort a child as it cannot defend for its self or use reason
-
Quality of life
-
Disability in the foetus
- They can be Aborted if screened and found to be disabled (physical or mental handicaps)
- Some people dislike this as the "disabled" child might live a full and loving life despite of the disability
- If every one did this there would be no "disabilities " in the human race
-
Equality and Disability
- People who are disables should not be discriminated against in any way
- Allow disabled people to live a full life
-
Pro-choice / Pro-life
-
Pro-choice
- Mothers choice in abortion
- The people involved concern
-
Pro-life
- Against Abortion
- wants child to be born
-
Rights to a child
-
Natural Law
-
Primary precept
- Reproduction
-
Infertility
- Inability to have a child
-
Ways to get around infertility
- IVF
- In-Vitro Fertilisation - outside the human body using sperms of the husband or donor and the egg of the wife or a donor egg.
- AID
- When donor sperm is used
- AIH
- Artificial Insemination by Husband , sperm injected into wives reproductive tract
-
Kantian Ethics
-
W.D Ross
-
Seven Prima Facie (at first sight) duties
- Fidelity
- Reparation for harm done
- Gratitude
- Justice
- Beneficence
- Self-improvement
- Not being Evil
-
THEY STRESS THE CHARACTER of DUTY.
- Must be considered in any moral situation
-
Contradictions in the Will
- universalise an act , does not contradict itself but results in an undesirable world to live in
-
Hypothetical Imperatives
- NOT moral commands
- Give instructions on how to achieve something else
-
Categorical Imperatives
- Absolute command that must always be followed
- Absolute moral obligations
- Every person is equally bound to follow the dictates of the Categorical Imperative
-
Contradictions in the law of Nature
- Universalising an act that would become contradictory to its self
-
Duty
- Good Wills only motive is Duty
- Some thing only contains good will if it is done out of your DUTY
- Its only motive is awareness that the act is right in itself
-
Freedom
- For Kant, it is vital that we recognise that we do have true freedom or autonomy of the will. with this freedom comes the responsibility to make a decision which is not swayed by desires or emotions
-
God
- Inherent justice in the world that ultimately virtuous or good behaviour would be rewarded (Summum Bonum ('highest good'))
-
Immorality
- Not all good acts are rewarded in this life
-
Reason
- Objective view of the good based on reason
- Moved away from Religion and Superstition , used Reason alone
- Pure and Practical reason could lead us to ethical decisions which are Universally Binding and NOT influenced by Fads or Fancies.
- Exists more or less in everyone
-
Good Will
- If Moral law is to be Binding it must contain something which is good in itself, with out reference to anything else
- The only thing Intrinsically good (Good in itself) is Good Will
- The intention not the results of the act makes Good Will
-
Christian ethics
-
Christian ethics can be found in
-
The Bible
-
Old testament
- Contains absolute laws with little room for felxibility , over 600 laws -> most famous 10 commandments
-
New testament
- Love God and love neighbour is two of the most important commandments , Beatitudes and sermon on the mount are the most famous
-
Ethics of Saint Paul
- Chrisitans should be guided by the Holy Spirit, (Summed up love thy neighbour)
-
The Church
- The Catholic church has a magisterium -> its teachings have a God given authority. The Pope is guided by the Holy Spirit
-
The Holy Spirit and Their Conscience
- Conscience supposedly is the voice of God . Inspiration from the inner dwellings of the Holy Spirit.
-
Natural law
- The theory than an absolute , external moral law can be discovered by using reason
-
Situation Ethics
- Law of LOVE. Fletcher -> we need to be prepared to abandon laws when love demands this
-
Proportionalism
- Compromise between Situation Ethics and Natural Law. Accepts certain acts are wrong and evil but if there is a proportionate reason preform the act
-
Virtue Ethics
- "sit" comfortably next to Natural Law. Common to see the CARDINAL VIRTUES as prudence
-
THEOLOGICAL VIRTUES
- Virtue
- Vice
- Humility
- Pride
- Liberality
- Averarice
- Brotherly Love
- Envy
- Meekness
- Wrath
- Chastity
- Lust
- Temperance
- Gluttony
- Diligence
- Sloth
- They are accompanied by the 7 CAPITAL VIRTUES (7 deadly sins) (left good virtues right bad virtues)
-
Divine Command Theory
- Ethics are objective because God is the supreme Moral Governor
-
Euthyro's Dilema
- 'Are things GOOD because God commands it, or are they GOOD and thats why God commands it'
-
Natural Moral Law
- Everything has a purpose.
-
Primary Precepts
- Worship God
- Ordered Society
- Reproduction
- Learning
- Defend the Innocent
-
Secondary Precepts
-
Absolute and Deontological principles
- Derived from primary precepts
- Found by use of REASON
- Must use Secondary Precepts to GET to Primary Precepts
-
Worship God (Primary precept)
- Found by being Religious (Secondary precepts)
-
Ordered Society (Primary precept)
- Found by Following laws (Secondary precepts)
-
Reproduction (Primary precept)
- Found by having Sexual intercourse(Secondary precepts)
-
Learning (Primary precept)
- Found by having an Education (Secondary precepts)
-
Defend the Innocent (Primary precept)
- Found by NOT Aborting an unborn child(Secondary precepts)
-
Efficient and Final cause
-
Efficent cause
- What gets things done
-
Final cause
- End product
-
Real and Apparent Goods
-
Real Good
- Preservation / Improvement of self
- Use reason to find this
-
Apparent Good
- "Good" things (eg drugs) that make us fall short of our potential
-
God
-
Human life should be 'Vision of God which is promised in the next life'
- Humans were made and should be the centre of Natural law
-
Casuistry and Double Effect
-
Casuistry
- This is the name given to Natural Law when applied to specific situations
-
Double Effect
- An 'un-wanted' side effect of Casuistry
-
Proportionalism
- There are certain moral rules that should never be broken unless there is a proportionate reason to do so