-
Theory of evolution
- Darwin: theory could be falsified by discovery of some complexity
-
If organ or organism:
- Is too complicated
- Could not have formed over long time period
- Does not appear to have any genetic antecedent
- Then evolutionary theory could be challenged
- Enough inconsistencies could lead to rejection of theory
-
Example of possible inconsistency:
- Theory: Reptiles evolved into birds.
- Reptiles have tough, protective, and/or leathery scales
- Birds have light wings with hollow bones for flight
-
Claim: Organisms at some intermediate stage (half scale, half wings) are at a disadvantage
- Lack protection
- Lack ability to fly
- Claim may weaken (or falsify) at least some portion of evolutionary theory
- Probably require many more examples for definite answer
-
Popper
- Falsification
- Scientific goal: falsify a theory
- If theory can be falsified, the theory is less adequate
- If possible, false theory may need to be replaced
-
Kuhn
-
Paradigm and paradigm shift
-
Paradigm
- "Normal" period of scientific progress
- Refining data and accepted experiments
- Modern example: evolutionary theory
-
Paradigm shift
- Revolutionary scientific discovery or contention
- Leads to acceptance of new theories and/or rejection of old ones
- Modern example: A definite paradigm shift would occur if evolution could be falsified
- New theory would be needed for scientific community
- Both modes supported by Lakatos