-
uses
- confirming cause effect association
- evaluating various treatment modality
- Evaluating feasibility, efficacy & relevance
-
example
-
experiment by Lind(1753)
- 12 pts aboard a ship with scurvy
- group into 6, 2 each
- given various regime of treatment
- 1 group given lemon and orange
- After 6 day, sudden improvement observed in group that consume orange and lemon
-
bypass study group 1985
- pts with cerebral ischaemia and obstructed int. carotid artery randomly put into medical and surgery
- surgical patient develop sickness earlier than medical team
-
smoking kills by pearl (1938)
- random assignment of smoker to an intensive intervention group or to a control group of "usual" management
- lower mortality rate in intervention group provide strong and incontrovertible .....................
-
selection criteria
-
inclusion
- guidelines for proper identification and gradation of cases by the extent and severity of disease to ensure selection of a homogenous study population
-
exclusion
- facilitate omission of patients suffering from atypical disease, any other disease, or disease associated with unusually poor prognosis
-
selection source
-
clinical trial
- randomization -ensure comparability of experimental and control group
-
risk intervention trial
- drawn from high risk population by cluster sampling technique
- to avoid operational industries,experimental and control groups should be drawn from identified but separate sources
-
preventive trials
- measure changes in the health picture specific preventive service programme or as a result of package of service encompasing in whole range of health prob
-
historical trial
- patient serve as their own control
- compared with their past experience prior to their participation in the trial
-
observation and interaction
-
consent
-
obtained after
- informing subject the purpose
- the procedure
- possible outcome of study
- so that they able to appreciate advantages and disadvantages assoc. with participation in proposed study
- consent given by participant on basis of information provided for them
-
compliance
- ensuring adherence of the subject to the medical advice of the investigator
- determine validity of experimental studies
- varies among different individual
- Individuals who fail to comply are excluded before the trial is formally initiated
-
several evolved approaches to ensure compliance
- counting unused pills, lab estimation of drug or metabolites in blood or urine or addition of safe biochemical markers
-
end point
- outcome event that appear during period of manipulation
-
positive
- return of sense of well being
- reduction of severity
- arrest of disease
- reduction of side effect and complication
-
negative
- comprise and acceleration of disease process
- increase its severity
- flare up of side effect and complications
- deterioration in the patient condition
-
analysis and inference
-
hospital based
- analysis involve periodic assessment of end point
-
community based
- efficacy measured on the basis of disease incidence using attributal risk
-
bias
-
selection bias
- highly selected
- inherently biased sample, suffering from a particular grade of a particular disease
-
observation bias
- aware of identity of experimental and control group member
-
can be eliminated
-
single blind study
- participant
-
double blind study
- participant and investigator
-
triple blind study
- participant, investigator and evaluator
-
placebo effect
- simulate therapeutic agent in color, taste, odor and physical appearance
-
critical estimate
-
technical
- resembles lab experiment in which changes produced in natural phenomena by dints of maneuver
-
operational
- compliance of participants is crucial issue
-
ethical
- based on ethical foundation