Complexity of brain just beginning to be understood
Freud's Training
Graduated medical school
Started as a researcher
Clinical practice started
Needed money
Started on Easter
Charcot
Ideas can cause symptoms
Problems not in the flesh
Problems in an idea
Ideas outside of awareness
Ideas can bring temporary cures
Hysteria
Considered common and chronic in women
Hysterics
Suffered from physical disabilities
Evidenced no obvious physical impairment
Considered by doctors of the time as
Malingerers
Morally suspect fakers
Generally weakened nervous system
Symptoms
Random
Meaningless
History of Diagnosis
First diagnosed in at least 4th century BC
APA dropped diagnosis in 1952
Ancient, medieval, Renaissance, and modern medical authorities before Freud characterized hysteria as a collection of "vague and sexually focused" symptoms
chronic arousal
anxiety
sleeplessness
irritability
nervousness
erotic fantasy
sensations of heaviness in the abdomen
lower pelvic edema
vaginal lubrication
History of Treatment
First Century AD & Earlier
Hippocritic corpus
Celsus
17th Century
Pieter van Foreest (1653)
When these symptoms indicate, we think it necessary to ask a midwife to assist, so that she can massage the genitalia with one finger inside, using oil of lilies, musk root, crocus, or [something] similar. And in this way the afflicted woman can be aroused to the paroxysm. This kind of stimulation with the finger is recommended by Galen and Avicenna, among others, most especially for widows, those who live chaste lives, and female religious, as Gradus [Ferrari da Gradi] proposes; it is less often recommended for very young women, public women, or married women, for whom it is a better remedy to engage in intercourse with their spouses.
19th Century
Pinel
Gall
Tripier
Briquet
Freud's Diagnosis
Disease of mind not of brain
Ideas, not nerves, are the origins of problems
Disturbing ideas connected to a stressful event
Not remembered by the patient
"Hysteria was caused by trapped memories and the feelings associated with them"
Memories and feelings never processed normally
Split off from the rest of the mind
Fester and rise to the surface as troubling and "seemingly inexplicable" symptoms
Content of the memories and feeling
Disturbing
Unacceptable
In conflict with the rest of the person's ideas and feelings
"incompatible with the rest of consciousness and were themselves actively kept out of awareness"
"Whereas Breuer saw hysterics as people susceptible to altered states of consciousness, to being 'spaced out,' Freud saw hysterics as people rent with conflicts and harboring secrests, from themselves as well as from others."
Freud's Treatment
Hypnosis
Breuer
Bertha Pappenheim
Anna O.
"chimney sweeping"
"talking cure"
Using hypnosis her associations lead back to origin of symptoms
Origin connected to a disturbing and forgotten memory
Talking leades to an emotional discharge
Emotional discharge followed by symptoms disappearing