Structure / Agency conudrum
Structure
=CONTEXT that exhibits certain regularities
Context = how things are set up
Repetition
Hidden Structure (Invisible)
i.e. Power
Individuals (agents) bearers of the structure = cannot do anything - they replicate the structure
Characteristics
In depth ontology
not just what we see
System based analysis
Synchrony
every single constituent has a role
looking at the bigger picture and understanding those roles
Determinism
predictability
Structuralism = Science
LImitations
the direction of causality
starting from A to B or B to A (which way?)
Determinism
predicting the future - which elements?
Agents to change the system (today)
Legitimacy Problem = subject object problem
who are those deciding
Examples
Dependency Theory
Hyper Globalisation Theory
Agency
= Conduct
Actors / Players
REFELXIVITY
ability to evaluate the course of our actions
Motivation and Intention
regarding or disregarding rules
Downplays the importance of structures
voter's behaviour
meritocracy = work hard to become rich
Personality of certain People
i.e. Rise and Fall of Saddam Hussain
Examples
Rational Choice / Neo Classical Economics?
Pluralism
Public Choice
Idealism
Dialectical Approaches
Mutually Constitutive
Structuration Giddens
Duality of Structure
Coin analogy
Bracketing Off
Structuration
Critique
Not a new way but neoliberlism with a human face
Strategic Relational Apporach
map figure 3.1. (insert pic)
Constructivism
Identity matters
Multiple Realities (constructed by individuals)
Interest = social construction
Intra and Inter-subjectivity
Role of Ideas
strategic w/o utility
appropriating of the context
Structure = Context
Morphogenetic approach
Structure comes first
Changes of structure postdate action
Archer (1996) picture
Structural Conditioning
Social Interaction
Structural elaboration
Material / Ideational
Ideational
Turner
Peripheral Concepts
Adjacentet Concepts
Neoliberalism =
=ideology
Primacy of ideas
Concepts and ideas
System of belief
Material
Vehicle to restore / preserve class power
Liberalism as a PROJECT
Neoliberalism =
best allocation of governance
particular form of capitalism
Marxis: capitalism = specific mode of production that is dispossessing people
Ideational-Material
Neo Gramscian
Cox
Neoliberalism =
Hegemonic Project
Material-Ideational
All Marxists are Materialists
Not all materialists are marxists
Harvey
Financial capital is different from Industrial capital
Marxian Tradition
ROA
Capital Creation
Capital Criculation
Capital Distribution
Four Types of Growth Regimes : capital extensive, capital intensive, mass consumption production, post-fordist
MOR
role of social pacts
role of ideas
role of legal frameworks
Neoliberalism =
regime created in a particular time?????
Definition
Dependent on the analytical lenses
Associated with Washington Consensus