better those who choose one thing above all others, immortal glory among mortals than the majority glutted like beasts
Plato's tripartite nature of soul
self asserting principle
honour through action
?
?
Aristotle conforms to tradition
honour is the prize for noblest deeds
greatest of external goods
what is paid to gods
intelligence
Odysseus
schemer
patriot
roots of the heroic, superhuman
Greek view of the Mycenaean kings after the Dark Ages
life ideal; manhood (what men should be and do)
honour
renown
personal worth
style and pride among men as notable
knew through a long tradition of oral poetry
conditions
small, self-sufficient city-states
nation of seafarers
opportunities for enterprise (e.g. war)
action
Hero (Great Man)
pursuit of honour through action
honour at the center of being
enlarged sense of personality and well being
enterprise
fame
applause of fellows
surpass other men
second existence
reward of honour
endowed with superior qualities
body
mind
excellence (utmost)
make the most out of his "gifts"
arete
dynamis
self-assertive principle of the soul
individualism
in the true heroic age Achilles fights not for his city, nor for his fellow Achaeans, but for his own glory
hero is an isolated, self-centered figure who lives and dies for a private satisfaction
in the service of the state
extension of manhood
Hector
war
brutality
insecurity, fear
treachery
injured pride
Alcibiades
The Athens I love is not the one which is wronging me now, but that one in which I used to have secure enjoyment of my rights as a citizen. The country that I am attacking does not seem to me mine any longer; it is rather that I am trying to recover a country that has ceased to be mine.
system of behavior
morality
honor
positive
vigorous action to many fields
constant
creation of opportunities
reflects the origin; a society whose first interest is war
applied to peace
Pericles' making of money
better their lot, make more of themselves and conditions e.g poverty
human dignity
arete of man
only court of appeal is a man's feelings
Topic
bound by obligations
forbidden actions; shame
conflict
merits of the Mean
middle state between obscurity and excessive power
morality of common sense
happiness
excess
incredible fortitude
forbidding inhumanity
death
true test of his worth; sacrifice the life which has meant more to him than to most men, thrown away in a gesture of defiance
climax and completion of life
sacrifice
Achilles doubts: But man's life will come not again, nor will it be captured/Once it has passed through his teeth, nor can any power restore it
Hector's civic frame, a man owes a supreme sacrifice to his people
a duty owed to fellow-men, unbreakable association, part of a greater unity more lasting than self
relations
friend
Topic
share another's fortunes
support with complete truth and faithfulness in loves and enmities, pleasuers and sorrows
scrupulously candid
fail in no call made upon him
Aristotle's schematic analysis of friendship, Nicomachean Ethics
mutual advantage
friendship lies in loving rather than in being loved; for the friend's sake
homosexuality
family
strong loyalties
older unit than state, prestige
pride for kith and kin because they belong to him; drive (biological)
standard of ancestors, worthy of the stock they were bred
duty of hatred, vengeance
women
not allowed any power
exception Artemisia of Halicarnassus
put aside, background, no cult of women, no public demonstration of affection
gave to friendship the attachment and loyalty which elsewhere accompany the love of women