-
Authorities
-
Moore v Regents of university of California (1990)
- Leukaemia patient claimed rights in cell line
-
Victoria Park Racing v Taylor (1937)
- Broadcasting commentary from view of racetrack
- Law of Property Act 1925 (LPA 1925) s205 (1) (ix)
-
Kelsen v Imperial Tobacco [1957]
- Advert overhanging shop front
-
Lord Bernstein of Leigh v Skyviews [1978]
- Plane taking aerial photos
-
Berkley v Poulett [1977]
- Paintings in panelling, statue on plinth, & sundial
-
Elitestone v Morris {1997]
- Bungalow resting on concrete footings
-
TSB v Botham [1996]
- White goods in flat
-
Property
- Property is NOT the owned object
-
Concepts of Property
(Gray & Gray, 1998)
-
Property as rights
-
'A bundle of rights'
- To possess
- To use
- To dispose of
- To exclude others
- Property as fact - possession
- Property as responsibility
-
Reasons for property rights
(Clarke & Kohler, 2005)
-
Allocate scarce resources
- No property in air or sea water!
- Encourage productive use
- To make a political/moral statement
-
What cannot be property?
-
Right to cell line
- Moore
-
A 'spectacle'
- Victoria Park Racing
-
Real & Personal
- 'Real' from Latin 'res' : A thing
-
Real Property
-
Right 'in rem' - to found a real action for real remedy
- i.e. to recover the actual thing e.g. plot of land
- Examples: freehold in land, heirloom, advowson
-
Personal Property
-
Right 'in personam' - to found a personal action
for personal remedy
- i.e. to recover damages (money)
- Examples: leasehold in land, chattels (moveable property)
-
Land
-
LPA 1925
-
Hereditaments
- Corporeal - land, buildings, minerals
- Incorporeal - manorial, easements
-
Airspace
-
Overhangs from adjacent land
- Kelsen
-
Airspace needed for ordinary use
- Bernstein
-
Fixtures
-
Test for fixtures
- Berkley v Poulett [1977]
Scarman LJ
-
Annexation
-
Method & degree
- Cannot be removed without damage
- creates presumption of fixture
-
Object & purpose
- To improve property (fixture)
or enjoy item (chattel)
-
Fixed by gravity?
-
'Third category' for immovable buildings
- 'Part of the land itself' (per Lloyd LJ)
- Elitestone
- Movable buildings - chattels
-
Domestic goods
-
Berkley 2 part test
- Fitted for use of house
e.g. fitted hob = fixture
- Placed in house to use or enjoy
e.g. freestanding oven = chattel
- TSB v Botham
-
Tenants fixtures
-
Fixtures treated as part of tenant's chattels
- For work