Remedies: rent
Implied covenant to pay rent
Express covenant also very likely
Debt
Can sue for debt
Distress
Landlord may levy distress
Seizes tenant's goods found on demised premises
Ancient self help remedy
May conflict with human rights
To be abolished
Forfeiture
Remedies: other breaches
Damages
Hadley v Baxendale (1854)
Arising naturally
Or in contemplation by both parties
Problem
s18 Landlord and Tenant Act 1927
Damages limited to fall in value of reversion
Repairs may cost more than this
Cannot recover at end of lease if will be pulled down
If lease gives right to enter to make repairs
Could repair and claim costs
This is recovery of a debt not damages
Specific performance
Discretionary equitable remedy
Only where damages inadequate
Hill v Barclay (1810)
General rule: not for positive obligations
Case concerned tenants obligation to repair
Jeune v Queens Cross Properties
Granted specific performance
Landlord's obligation to repair
Rainbow Estates Ltd v Tokenhold Ltd
Repairing covenent against tenant
Granted specific performance
s11 Landlord and Tenant Act 1985
If applies
Expressly provides that tenant may obtain specific performance against landlord
Injunction
Discretionary remedy
Set off against rent
Self help remedy for tenant
Cannot just withold rend if landlord fails to fulfill obligations
Taylor v Beal
Must notify landlord that repairs needed
And that will carry out if landlord fails to
May deduct cost from future rent payments
Forfeiture
Forfeiture
Allows landlord to terminate fixed term lease early
Also terminates any under-leases
Where...
Lease contains clause allowing landlord to re-enter property for breach
OR lease granted subject to right to forfeit on some event
OR tenant denies the landlord's title
Landlord may waive the breach
Must not accept or demand rent
Unless is continuing breach
eg repairs
Non-payment of rent
Formal demand
Must attend at premises on final day before sunset
Lease may dispense with need to make formal demand
Not necessary if more than six months in arrears
Common Law Procedure Act 1852
County Courts Act 1984
Peaceable re-entry
Not if a dwelling house
s2 Protection from Eviction Act 1977
OR forfeiture proceedings
Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002
Lease of more than 21 years of a dwelling house
Not liable to pay rent unless notice given between 30 and 60 days
s166
Cannot forfeit unless more than certain amount payable for more than prescribed period
s167
Relief from forfeit
Forfeiture proceedings: High Court
Pays all arears and costs into court before proceedings
May apply for relief within 6 months of order for possession
Forfeiture proceedings: County Court
s138 County Courts Act 1984
Pays all arears and costs five days before proceedings
Court will order possession within period not less than four weeks
Can avoid forfeiture if pays all arears and costs within this period
Can apply for relief within 6 months
Peaceable re-entry: High Court
Equitable jurisdiction to relieve
No specific time limits
Six months as a guide
Peaceable re-entry: County Court
Six months time limit applies
County Courts Act 1984
Factors
Only where equitable to do so
Should not delay
Will need to pay arrears and costs
Other breaches
Must contain forfeiture clause
s146 Law of Property Act 1925
Landlord must serve notice on tenant
Must specify particular breach
Require lessee to remedy if possible
Or require compensation in money
s168 Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2000
May not serve notice under s146 unless
has applied to leasehold valuation tribunal
OR tenant has admitted breach
OR court or arbitral tribunal has determined breach
Applies to long leases of dwelling house
May forfeit by serving proceedings
No further right to relief once court order obtained
Or by peaceable re-entry
May still apply for relief
Billson v Residential Apartments Ltd [1992]
Repairing breaches
If lease more than 7 years and unexpired term more than 3 years
Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938
Must serve notice under s146 LPA 1925
Whether damages or forfeiture
Must inform of right to serve counter notice within 28 days
If serves, landlord must go to court
Will need to show value of reversion substantially diminished
Or repairs much more expensive if delay
Damages
s18 Landlord and Tenant Act 1927
Capped at fall in value of reversion
Or may use right to enter to repair
Claim cost of repairs from tenant